Thinking Task of 'Dryden's essay'

-
1) Do you any difference between Aristotle's definition of Tragedy and Dryden's definition of Play?
2) If you are supposed to give your personal predilection, would you be on the side of the Ancient or the Modern? Please give reasons.
3) Do you think that the arguments presented in favour of the French plays and against English plays are appropriate? (Say for example, Death should not be performed as it is neither 'just' not 'liely' image, displaying duel fight with blunted swords, thousands of soldiers marching represented as five on stage, mingling of mirth and serious, multiple plots etc.)
4) What would be your preference so far as poetic or prosaic dialogues are concerned in the play? 

1) Yes, the definition of both critics has different aspects in one or the other way. As far as the definition of Aristotle is concern, he defined tragedy as an ‘ideal’ representation of life. While the definition of Dryden says that is should be ‘just’ and ‘lively’ image of human life, and he has added delight also in the representation of life. Aristotle’s definition has ended with ‘catharsis’ while the definition of Dryden has ‘delight’.
2) If I suppose to give my personal predilection, I would like to be on the side of modern, because ancients have followed the rules and disciplines, and moderns have not only followed or imitated them but also have given something new with the help of new inventions in that era like in science and changes in the social world. Ancient used to write in different kind of boundaries like unities and as per the Greek tradition some scenes were not allowed to perform on stage. So the freedom of action is not there.
3) The arguments have presented in the favor of French and against of English plays are not appropriate in one or the other way because it’s true that French plays have its own rules and discipline. There are certain psychological reasons of all the actions in the play, and it has always proper manner of writing. It believes that the death should not be presented on stage and there should be only a narration of it. As far as English plays are concern they strongly believe that death scene should be performed because it can be have a great effect on the audience though it is not ‘just’ and ‘lively’. In English plays there are multiple plots woven together which used to support the main plot and helps the action to take place and tries to increase the interest of audience. The sense of realistic representation is there in the English plays. For E.g. Othello, there is a death scene in it, and in Hamlet there is a war and fighting scenes, but only description of those parts could not be effective as performance can do.
4) I would like to be preferred with prosaic dialogue, because as far as routine and common conversation is concern poetic language cannot give more justice to it, Poetic dialogues can define a very higher state of emotions like pain, catharsis, love and etc. As far as all the plays are concerned, there should be many kinds of themes in it, for e.g. a king cannot order his servant in poetic manner.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dr.Faustus as a tragedy.

-
Image
Respected sir,              To evaluate my assignment click here   Name:- Heerva Bhatt Course:- M.A. (sem.1) Paper no.:- 1(The Renaissance Literature ) Topic name:- Dr.Faustus as a tragedy. Roll no.:-14 Email Id:- heervabhatt96@gmail.com  Submitted to :-Smt.S.B.Gardi Department of  English, Bhavnagar.  Introduction :-                             Christopher Marlowe(1564-1593)is one of the most suggestive figures of the English Renaissance, and the greatest of Shakespeare’s predecessors.                            Marlowe was born in Canterbury, only a few months before Shakespeare. He was the son of a poor shoemaker, but through the kindness of a patron was educated at the town grammar school and then at Cambridge. When he came to London, his soul was surging with the ideals of the Renaissance, which later found expression in Faustus ,the scholar longing for unlimited knowledge and for power to grasp the universe.                            In 1587,when but twenty
Read more

Aristotalian tragedy vs shakespearean tragedy

-
Image
Respected sir,            To evaluate my assignment click here  Name:-Heerva Bhatt Course :-M.A. (sem.1) Paper no.:- 3(Literary theory and                         Criticism ) Roll no.:- 14 Email Id :-heervabhatt96@gmail.com  Submitted to :-Smt.S.B.Gardi Department of English, Bhavnagar.  Introduction :-                            Tragedy  (Greek word)is a former of drama based on human suffering that invokes an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in audiences. While many cultures have developed forms that provoke this paradoxical response, the term tragedy often refers to a specific tradition of drama that has played a unique and important role historically in the self-definition of Western civilisation.That tradition has been multiple and discontinuous,yet the term has often been used to invoke a powerful effect of cultural identity and historical continuity - "The Greeks and the Elizabethans, in one cultural form;Hellens and Christians, in a common activity."
Read more

Social, Religious and political background in Kanthapura.

-
Image
Respected sir,           To evaluate my assignment click here  Name:-Heerva Bhatt Course:-M.A. (sem.1) Paper no.:-4(Indian Writing in English) Topic name:- Social,Religious and                          political background in                          Kanthapura.  Roll no.:-14 Email Id :-heervabhatt96@gmail.com  Submitted to :-Smt.S.B.Gardi Department of English, Bhavnagar.       Introduction :-                               Raja Rao is one of the greatest of Indian novelists writing in the English language.Only two others -Mulk Raj Anand and R.K.Narayan-come any where near him.But Raja Rao is entirely different from them in his art as a novelist,and in his enchanting prose style.This pre-eminence is surprising when we remember that the bulk of his published work is small. His works:- □ The Cow of the Barricades and other stories (1947) □   Kanthapura  (1938) □  The Serpent an the Rope (1960) □ The Cat and Shakespeare  (1965)                       Raja Rao'
Read more